Spinning the Somme

On 1st July (resonant date), I'm doing a lecture at the IWM as part of the Museum's 'First World War Remembered' Day. This has grown out of study days for students which I've been running with the Head of Research and Information, Nigel Steel. The day involves curators and historians talking about artefacts and describing how they're put together to create history – academic, public and popular. On that note, it's interesting to note how the Museum's publicity department has chosen to describe the subject in its website entry on the day:

    When the First World War began in August 1914 many believed it      would be over by Christmas, but the power of modern weapons quickly turned it into a bitter struggle. For more than four years soldiers on both sides fought a series of infamous battles at Ypres, Verdun, Gallipoli and the Somme. Millions of lives were lost and little appeared to be gained. The First World War represented a turning point in history and its impact can still be felt on communities across the world today.

Those who know me and my work will know that this is not exactly the description of the war I would go for. I realise that it's necessary to engage and interest a non-specialist audience, but I can't help but see this as a kind of 'default setting', piling a set of cliches one on top of another. 

But it highlights an area which I've been interested in for some time. I've always wanted to be a historian whose work reached a popular audience. If you want to do that, you need to get the punters in, and you probably need to accept that you'll come up against cliche and lack of thought – so the issue is how do you react to that? Do you throw a massive hissy fit and throw your toys out of the pram? Or do you go for a sort of entryism, in which you try to sneak in the uncertainties and ambiguities of history and try to help the audience think critically about their received beliefs? If you do the latter, have you in fact sold your soul – because your ability to get that information across will probably be limited by format, time and audience? Where do you draw the line?  

In my book and in an article recently written for BBC History online (but not yet up), I've tried to suggest that First World War historians probably shouldn't get too frustrated with the fact that myths about the war are too entrenched for us to shift. Better that people use those myths, care about the war, remember those who fought, and – in a minority of cases – try to find out more – than that the war is completely forgotten.  

(And let's leave aside for the moment the fact that in the Museum's email newsletter I'm described as well known Queen Mary historian Dr Dan Thompson. Obviously not that well known…)  

Advertisements

4 Responses to Spinning the Somme

  1. Chris Williams says:

    I had a few similar thoughts when I was asked to a little bit for the web spin-off from the forthcoming OU/BBC Battle of the Somme programme. Same reaction, too – although if the preview info is anything to go by, the show won’t be a complete ‘July 1st-fest’. It will recognise that two other armies took part, for example.

  2. Dan says:

    Any news about when/where it’ll be on, Chris? I think that the most positive thing that’s happened in terms of ‘Somme Studies’ is the recognition that it was an international battle. Lots of reasons for that recognition, of course, but it does seem to be having a real impact on what gets said and shown publicly. Interesting to ponder whether the Somme could ever function for the UK, France and Germany as Verdun does for the latter two?

  3. Chris Williams says:

    Good question . . . I’ve got the glossy OU TV mag, and all it says is ‘on BBC ONE this summer, check the press for details’ which is less than helpful.

  4. Ryan Gearing says:

    The BBC docudrama looks like its scheduled for 2nd July

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: